23/01/12

Comparing JAIL4Judges With All Other Proposals

Dr. Joseph Zernik, what you have described below is about a good description of judicial immunity as can be stated. It matters not what the law, or judicial decisions are regarding judicial immunity. The only thing judges are forbidden from doing is embarrassing the judicial system. In that regard, murder, bank robbery, rape, car jacking, bribery and extortion performed by judges are all within the realm of "acceptable judicial conduct covered by judicial immunity." We need to forget defining judicial immunity according to published law or printed judicial decisions, the first and greatest of all commandments is, "Thou shalt not embarrass the judicial system!" Never is any judge prosecuted for evil doing, or for the commission of any crimes.

I have said numerous times in public presentations, we have no laws that govern the U.S. The "law" is whatever the judges say at any given time. When judges open their mouth, what comes out of their lips is "the law." Two plus two equals whatever conclusion is desired! Forget about what you learned in school. "Fraud" is their name, and deception their game!

When I hear someone tell me about a dishonest judge, I know I am speaking with someone who is a novice. The judicial system is irreparably broken. Looking to "legislation" will only install another layer of deception over the top of existing fraud. It is like repainting a house that is totally eaten through and taken over by termites. Another coat of paint will to no good! Paint will only make the house look more livable, but you know you are in trouble when your leg passes through the floor when you take one step inside the front door!

When I say "J.A.I.L. is the only answer," I know that means we have to remove all the rotten wood in a house that is 100% rotten. But people do not want to hear something so drastic. So I just say, "Let's fix up the judicial system with judicial accountability." Most everyone agrees that a fixer-upper effort must be employed on our judiciary, but what people do not agree upon is that we must start with a bulldozer and not even save the rusty nails.

When the people start throwing the evil judges to the hungry lions within the J.A.I.L. lions den, then, and only then with the "good" judges will submit their application for retirement. But the provision within J.A.I.L. will not allow judges to escape by retirement, for basically, three-strikes will overtake them on their pre-existing record before they can enjoy the fruits of retirement. And consider the retroactive provision of J.A.I.L. If there once existed law that provided for a remedy, it can never go away. The judiciary cannot escape the sting of those current laws. Hence, your statement, "In short: I am not opposed to new legislation, but we must demand to prosecute the judges even under current law, not let them get away for racketeering!" is all totally covered within the passage of Judicial Accountability Initiative Law (J.A.I.L.)

As one, who supports your cause, I just wanted to comment, that even under current law the judges are not immune to most of their crimes.

The most common form of judicial corruption today is through the issuance of simulated court records. The judges, who engage in such conduct are NOT under any immunity, since they are engaged in extrajudicial conduct in doing so - presiding in cases, to which they were not assigned, and with no judicial authority and immunity at all.

Regardless, neither the US congress, nor anybody else holds them accountable. The best documented case of this type is the case of the corrupt US Judge Manuel Real, who was caught grabbing the court file of a woman he knew with no assignment and no authority. She was under bankruptcy procedures, and he basically stopped the case to help her. He was caught, US Congress did nothing, and Steven Yagman, who blew the whistle went to federal prison for several years on IRS violations, that some said others would only be fined for. In his sentencing heaering, Yagman quoted Kafka: "a case went looking for a bird..."

What is most lacking is public demand for holding the judges accountable. In that department, there is no doubt that you are a pioneer!

In short: I am not opposed to new legislation, but we must demand to prosecute the judges even under current law, not let them get aways for racketeering!

Comparing JAIL4Judges to All Other Proposals
The problem with political bodies handling the subject of judicial accountability, is politics and special interests. It must be understood that no man can be trusted because of the propensity of mankind to evil. The distinction with JAIL4Judges is that it creates a rotating Special Grand Jury in which no one sits on the Special Grand Jury for more than a year, and is thereafter disqualified. The public becomes involved only by a random drawing.

Members of the Bar Assoc., law enforcement, and all judicial employees are excluded for obvious reasons. No government prosecutors are allowed, but only qualified members of the public may serve this Grand Jury as Prosecutors, Investigators, and Advisers who submit their applications to the Grand Jury for such positions. This Grand Jury is totally autonomous, and only has jurisdiction over issues of willful violations of laws or of the State or U.S. Constitutions.

No judge may be defended at public expense in answering to this Special Grand Jury. Upon any conviction by a panel of jurors, only the jurors may impose sentences, not any other judge or judicial officer. In this manner, all politics are separated from its operations, and only the people determine for themselves the plite of all judicial offenders. It just cannot get any better than JAIL4Judges!

04/01/12

Can Parliament's supermacy be thwarted by few individuals?

Lokpal Bill is being debated in Indian Parliament for three days from 27-29 December, 11, which is an extended session, otherwise, the Parliament would have been dissolved after the winter session by now. This special privilege has been given to the so called civil society agitation movement under Anna Hazare.
 

The nation thanks the civil society agitation, as it gave a much awaited momentum for the govt. to speed up the process of bringing the Lokpal Bill in the current session itself. This was after the first widely acclaimed fast by Anna Hazare at Jantar Mantar that lasted for about 13 days, which made the UPA govt. to come up with this Bill now. 

The Union Law and Justice Minister Salman Khurshid, through his article  “A Question of Balance” (TOI 27 Dec 2011), has given enough reasoning for not agitating only against the non-inclusion of the CBI in the ambit of the Lokpal Bill, as, he argues ,in that case, not only the CBI but the entire gamut of army, police, Para-military organizations, nuclear command/control facility et.al should be under its ambit. No govt. can function credibly under such a watchdog. After all, it is a parliamentary democracy and here only the supremacy of the people of the country as a whole is vested with such authority to challenge a constitutionally elected govt. and not an individual or a few disgruntled individuals with the support of certain other groups or anti-govt. organizations.

The question of reservation in the 9 member body of Lokpal too is a matter that creates problem for parties that traditionally oppose such reservation. But, the country after having experienced the dominance of the high and mighty, the literates and the higher echelons, for centuries, pre-independence vis-a-vis two or three decades post independence , cannot just avoid or overlook the representation to every sections of the society in a high powered anti-corruption set up like the Lokpal at this critical juncture. The biggest anti-reservation agitation was against the reservation to the OBC community and that too was finally accepted and assimilated in the Indian system with suitable alteration/modification like the creamy layer etc. Therefore, the sentiments of the nation as a whole need to be taken care of when a new set up to look on a monstrous dragon like the corruption that has taken this country to abysmal depth amongst the comity of nations.

No political party in India is clean and can claim they are washed in milk in so far as the corruption issue is concerned. Therefore, the need of bringing a strong Lokpal is felt sine long and now we are discussing it in Parliament for three days. There are reportedly several demands for changes in the Bill of which the strong ones are like “include CBI” and “Scrap reservation” (by BJP), amendments like “creation of a separate investigative wing” under the Lokpal and also inclusion of “Corporate Crimes” to be investigated under Lokpal etc. (by the CPM). All these aspects will be discussed threadbare by representatives of political parties who will be given time in proportionate representation basis. The debate will run throughout in Parliament while Anna Hazare and his team will be on fast at Mumbai and Delhi respectively. Hazare’s latest move to sit on a day’s fast at Sonia Gandhi’s residence is also quite disturbing. But, the main disturbing question that agitates the minds of every sensible Indian citizen is : whether Anna Hazare & his team of couple of individuals represents a whole nation to browbeat and bring down a duly elected govt.?

27/12/11

Is Judicial System Part of the Crime Problem?

I am more concerned about the innocent being convicted than the "guilty" going free. The judges are not supposed to work with the prosecutors; they are required to be unbiased. If 80% of people are found innocent or the charges are dismissed, the problem may be too many arrests of innocent people or for minor violations. The US has 2.6 million people in jail. Listen to the comments by Presidential candidate Gary Johnson on the state of the legal system. Putting more people in jail is not a solution to crime. Governor Perry just pardoned a death row victim who was innocent. Dr. Katy Hoover

Clearfield Doctrine :

"Governments descend to the Level of a mere private corporation, and take on the characteristics of a mere private citizen...where private corporate commercial paper [Federal Reserve Notes] and securities [checks] is concerned. ... For purposes of suit, such corporations and individuals are regarded as entities entirely separate from government." - 

Clearfield Trust Co. v. United States 318 U.S. 363-371 (1942). What the Clearfield Doctrine is saying is that when private commercial paper is used by corporate government, then Government loses its sovereignty status and becomes no different than a mere private corporation. 

As such, government then becomes bound by the rules and laws that govern private corporations which means that if they intend to compel an individual to some specific performance based upon its corporate statutes or corporation rules, then the government, like any private corporation, must be the holder- in-due-course of a contract or other commercial agreement between it and the one upon whom demands for specific 
performance are made. 

And further, the government must be willing to enter the contract or commercial agreement into evidence before trying to get to the court to enforce its demands, called statutes. 

This case is very important because it is a 1942 case after the Erie RR v. Tomkins 304 U.S. 64, (1938) case in which the Legislatures and Judiciary changed from legislating under "Public Law", which was in consonance with the CONstitution, to legislating under "Public Policy" according to the wishes of the "Creditors of the US Corporation".